Friday, 16 May 2014

DRAMA 2013 - Turn Around Project’s Applied Theatre Techniques with RAFT – Niagara


Taylor 1


Final Paper – RAFT / Turn Around Project
Monica Taylor - 4522884
Prof: Carolee Mason
DART 3P04
March 27, 2013


Turn Around Project’s Applied Theatre Techniques with RAFT – Niagara

        To begin to understand the applied theatre project that I am proposing for the Resource Association for Teens (RAFT) it is beneficial to understand the Turn Around Project. I am assessing the existing connections between the Turn Around Project and the RAFT and proposing changes and the addition of an applied theatre component to the Turn Around Project’s association with the RAFT. This report will outline the background of the Turn Around Project and the RAFT as well as providing a description of clients and staff as well as the needs of the group. The proposed workshops will be outlined and provide rationale to its efficacy. To conclude, this report will explore the anticipated outcomes of the project.
        The Turn Around Project (TAP) was created September of 2006 at Brock University when Dub Poet Michael St. George was hired to teach a class called “Alternative Forms of Theatre”. TAP became a group of students who had a desire to work with Jamaican youth. The goal was to foster positive attitudes, generate change, and bring awareness to alternative ways of thinking. Since 2006 TAP has been in charge of summer trips to Jamaica, India,
Taylor 2

Japan and locally in Canada (Turn Around Project). These trips bring arts supervisors and session leaders to these areas to work with disadvantaged youth and to give them an outlet of expression and education through the world of arts. Meaghan Gowrie, a member of TAP and session leader in Jamaica had this to say about the experience; 

“Our mandate is to connect communities through the arts. So we offer a variety of workshops in music, dance, theatre, film, photography, visual arts, culinary arts etc. We try to enforce communication, peace, love, unity and respect through them. In the past five years we’ve done projects in Jamaica, India, Japan and Niagara. We look for communities that have been affected in one way or another. So we do projects at the RAFT (homeless shelter for teens) in Bhopal India (where people are facing the effects of the chemical explosion 20 years ago) and Jamaica (where we bring half of the youth from the inner city, and half from the country because there is a lot of conflict and hostility between the two groups) (Gowrie).”

        Meaghan is one of the many volunteers that assist the not-for-profit organization that has grown to incorporate many dramatic and artistic educators around the world. The drama facilitators, for example, work with groups of eight to twelve youth in one workshop a day for two weeks. The facilitators run two workshop groups consecutively, one in the morning and one in the afternoon. A typical session for TAP to run is eight weeks. The drama facilitators in this time will spend forty hours with each youth member over the course of the summer. In Jamaica, specifically, the drama facilitators use applied theatre to address the conflicts that have been created between the youth of Jamaica. Youth from the city and youth from the country are brought together by applied theatre in order to understand each other and eventually come to an understanding and respect for each
Taylor 3

other through applied theatre practices.
                It was these practices of conflict resolution that I believe would be beneficial to the RAFT. In 1994, in response to the lack of services provided in the Niagara region for at risk youth and homeless youth, the RAFT was opened. Community groups, service clubs, the faith community and concerned individuals in the Niagara community, fund the RAFT. The program provides many services to homeless or at risk youth in the community such as the original drop in center operating five nights a week. The RAFT expanded to include a “16 bed 24/7 hostel, a Steps to Independent Living Program, a Regional Transportation program, a community based Youth Reconnection Program and Community Development Initiatives aimed at strengthening stressed neighborhoods and empowering at-risk youth” (The Raft Helps). The community development initiatives are aimed at reducing and preventing the number of at-risk youth in Niagara. Through its Neighborhood Awakening Initiative, the RAFT helps build stronger, caring communities in Niagara by engaging potential at – risk youth and fostering their empowerment, independence and self-esteem. I believe that an additional resource (applied theatre workshops) would provide a program for these youth that would enable them to see their projected and current successes and help prepare them emotionally for next steps they want to take.

Taylor 4

Workshops and Activities Outline               

Conflict resolution is the motivation behind bringing Turn Around Project facilitation techniques to the RAFT. The Turn Around Project drama facilitators use drama games, activities and discoveries to foster an inclusive environment of learning and wondering. There are many ways to resolve conflict. Many responses chosen by people result in an escalation of the conflict. Physical violence, war, verbal abuse and silent treatments are some reactions to conflict. It is essential that the participating youth learn how to communicate with themselves and with others about conflict that can arise on a day-to-day basis. The applied theatre program may seem like just games and activities but it is building an essential skill set that will assist these youth in achieving a happy, fulfilling life.
The program will be run on a day – to – day basis to adhere with the needs of these Niagara youth. Most youth stay approximately six days but some only stay one night and some others for longer. It is unreasonable to ask these youth to commit to a five-day program when they may feel that they cannot commit or may feel pressured into showing up. A drop in daily program would be the most beneficial style of program delivery for this clientele.
As each day would be different, a common theme will run throughout them so that the returning youth feel like they are experiencing something new and learning something new but new clients will not feel like they are intruding on an already on going process. The goal is to create an inclusive environment that fosters the safe and creative venture into self-discovery and conflict resolution through applied theatre. To give an example of a “typical

Taylor 5

program day” a breakdown will be provided below for the hour that the facilitator will have with the youth.

Warm Up:  5 – 15 Minutes
Augusto Boal’s “The Structure of the Actor’s Work” provides activities that assist in developing awareness and control of emotions. The warm ups that will start every session will be chosen based on Boal’s principal that will aid in understanding personal emotions and emotions of others when deconstructing the meaning and resolution of conflict. Boal describes how “like all human beings, the actor (the at risk youth in this case) acts and reacts in a repetitive way for this reason, we must start with the ‘de-mechanization’, the returning (or detuning) of the actor, so that he may be able to take on the mechanisms (of other people involved in the conflict in this case) of the character he is going to play. He must relearn to perceive emotions and sensations he has lost the habit of recognizing” (Boal 30). Muscular, sensory, memory, imagination and emotion exercises are provided to achieve a level of emotional understanding that will help the at risk youth find a base to their opinions and beliefs about the conflicts in their lives.

First Activity “Two Revelations”:  15 Minutes
         In his book, Michael Rohd lists several conflict-preventative dramatic activities that he has collected. An activity called 'Two Revelations' helps rid of conflict that might arise in the future. The basic idea of this activity involves secrets. Two people form a pair and each member of the team comes up with a secret. One of the team members reveals his or her
Taylor 6

secret to the other. When the secret has been revealed, both individuals have to talk about them and identify what misconceptions were formed by keeping this secret. This activity portrays the malicious effects of secrecy and distrust. Rohd provides an example: “John and Jane are in a team together. John thinks up of a personal secret. Jane thinks one up too. Then John reveals what his secret was. Let's say that secret was that he hates Jane because she always uses him to cheat on a test. Jane might have been thinking all along that John doesn't mind. The bitter mistrust between them would grow. Then Jane takes her turn to reveal a secret” (Rohd). When both secrets have been revealed, a lot of mistrust evaporates. This shows the individuals who don't keep any secrets have a greater possibility of avoiding conflict.
Second Activity “Bad Sentence Structure”:  15 Minutes
      Once the youth have experienced an activity that reveals the issues that can arise from a festering conflict (example provided: two revelations), the follow up activity will provide the youth with a possible solution or a new conflict resolution skill. An activity outlined by Patricia Sternberg in her book Theatre for Conflict Resolution: In the Classroom and Beyond provides an activity called “Bad Sentence Structure”. She recommends making lists of sentence that promote the reduction of bad behavior. For example “rather than saying ‘I hate you,’ which might antagonize the other person, you could say, ‘I hate what you said about me.’ This may cause a change in the behavior because unlike the first sentence that attacks the person as a whole, the second doesn’t target the individual but rather the behavior of that particular individual” (Sternberg). This activity will provide the youth with an applicable example to conflict resolution. It is recommended that the facilitator attempt to encourage
Taylor 7

youth to share their conflict sentence resolutions to the group to give the group more examples to think about. Of course, if the youth are not comfortable with sharing they are not expected to. Forcing youth in these situations to step way outside their comfort zone may lead to disruptive behavior, walking out and the choice to not attend any more sessions.

Wrap Up/ Cool Down: 10 Minutes
         It is always important to debrief with a group after teaching them something. I love the quote that is out these that to teach someone something effectively you must first tell them what you are about to teach them, teach it to them and then recap what you just taught them. The debrief acts as the portion of the session where a solid conclusion can be driven home to the youth. It provides time for individuals to discuss issues that may have arisen during the hour or in their personal lives. These cool down activities will usually be facilitated in a circle so the group members can feel connected and on equal playing fields with their peers. Having the facilitators sit on the floor (or chairs) with the youth provides the visual and emotional sensation that the facilitators are approachable and accessible. The cool down can consist of the facilitator posing a question that stimulates community discussion. The facilitator could provide the group with a conflict scenario and have the group come up with a solution together using the skills that they had learned that day. 

Taylor 8

Anticipated Outcomes
Boal brings life to the anticipated outcomes for this kind of theatre; “ We cannot live in isolation, under arrest inside ourselves. We can learn enormously when we recognize ourselves in alterity: the Other also loves and hates, fears and has courage – just like me, like you, even though he/she, you and I have cultural differences. Precisely because of that, we can learn from each other: we are different, being the same” (Boal 2). Providing a drop in conflict workshop through applied theatre techniques will be essential component to ensuring that the needs of all clients are met. There are many at risk youth that will benefit from hands on application of conflict resolution skills. The workshops have the main goal of learning strategies and perspectives on conflict resolution but the self-discovery that happens during these sessions can have positive influences on other aspects of their lives as well. Building confidence, awareness, community skills, communication skills and empathy can assist these youth in understanding the world around them. These activities for this client group are activities that they may not have the opportunity to access in other venues. Many times, at risk youth miss out on extra curricular activities both in and after school. The applied theatre drop in workshops at the RAFT will provide these clients with opportunities they may not get elsewhere.
            I will test the efficacy of these workshops by providing a method for feedback from the youth. Anonymous cards will be available for the youth to write their concerns and wishes on to assist the tailoring of the program to the specific needs of the clients.


Taylor 9

References

Boal, Augusto. Games for Actors and Non – Actors: Second Edition. Abingdon: Routledge,           2002. Print. 

Gowrie, Meaghan. Personal Interview. 5 March. 2013. 

Rohd, Michael. Theatre for Community, Conflict & Dialogue: The Hope is Vital Training             Manual. Portsmouth: Heinemann, 1998. 

Sternberg, Patricia. Theatre for Conflict Resolution: In the Classroom and Beyond.            Portsmouth: Heinemann. 1998. 

The Raft Helps – Resource Association For Teens. Niagara Resource Service For Youth.    Web Page. Accessed: March 20, 2013. 

Turn Around Project – Connecting Communities Through The Arts. The Turn Around      Project of the Arts. 2012. Web page. Accessed: March 20, 2013.

DRAMA 2013 - Analysis of a Situation Drama: Erin Brockovich


Taylor 1
Monica Taylor – 4522884
Professor Gyllian Raby
TA: Katherine Gottli
DART 2P92
February 16, 2013
Word Count: 1750

Analysis of a Situation Drama: Erin Brockovich

Universal Pictures and Jersey Films turned the true story of legal assistant Erin Brockovich into a movie in 2000. The discrepancies between the true story and the Hollywood version staring Julia Roberts allow for analysis of how and why the writers chose certain details to change. This paper will use John Vorhaus and Kenneth Burke’s vocabulary to follow the heroine’s journey through the drama as carefully constructed and written by the writers at Universal Pictures.

Who is the hero?
Erin Brockovich is a mother of three desperate for a job. After a string of bad luck incidents, Brockovich gets into a car accident and attempts to file a lawsuit against the other driver, and in the process lands a job at that law firm she goes to.  It is this scene where Brockovich’s motivation is revealed to the audience and a pivotal shift in her life happens. Although this scene is at the beginning of the movie,
                                                                                                                                     Taylor 2
the audience is well aware through the description of never ending obstacles in her way, this moment seems to be her big break.

            It is in these opening scenes that Erin’s character motivations are revealed. Relating these clearly to the audience is important according to Kenneth Burke as he defines motives as “acceptable justifications for present, future, or past programs of conducts, used tribally to influence and persuade others” (Burke 3). The success of Erin’s character is based strictly on her motives as she comes into the story with not much to offer her current situation. Her personal motive is to get a job, any job at this point to support her family. As she does a little research into working for the law firm she begins to demonstrate to the audience her categorical motive, which Burke defines as “economic or pragmatic social utility” which is to assist, the underdogs (the town of Hinkley) beat the giant corporation of PG&E in a classis David vs. Goliath show down (Burke 3). Finally she exposes (use of exposition) her generic motive, which is to prove that any woman, regardless of education, if they work hard can be as successful as any well-educated man.

What does the hero want?
Brockovich successfully browbeats Ed Masry, her layer, into giving her a job at the firm. It is here we learn of her obstacles, which make this story, and the adapted script so interesting as the obstacles reveal the dramaturgy used to understand the philosophical implications of a script’s motive. The story of Erin
                                                                                                                                     Taylor 3

Brockovich is an up and down struggle of status both internally and externally. Both are intricately linked to each other and her needs. Her inner need is to feel justified which she has not been able to do thus far in her life, as she has no education and limited work experience. Her outer need is to provide for her three children and maintain (and improve) her lifestyle. The way Brockovich presents herself physically, revealing clothing, big hair, make up and a ‘no bullshit’ attitude reveals to the audience the low level of self-esteem she has. The audience watches her status shift and subsequently her self esteem rise over the course of the movie through her clothing choices as she uses her physical assets less to accomplish goals and uses her mind. It is her cultural belief that she should be able to do this right out of the gate instead of having to get there with her body and prove her worth with her mind.  It is these stand off moments between Brockovich and head Lawyer Ed Masry that are essential to the hero’s plot development, status shifts and motivation exploration as she routinely dramaturgically plays with Masry to get her way and to raise her status up. This is a change that the writers at Universal Pictures changed for the movie as the real life Erin Brockovich was hired by an assistant of Masry and did not have much contact with him during the start of her process of taking on PG&E. (the electric company she sues).



                                                                                                                                     Taylor 4
The Door Opens
Brockovich spends a week visiting the residents of Hinkley collecting back-stories and attempting to make connections between illnesses and the hexavalent chromium that PG&E leaked into their water. When she returns to the office, she finds that her stuff has been cleared from her desk. Furious, she proves her status by barging into Masry’s office and demanding an explanation. As a shock to Brockovich, Masry explains that in the ‘real world’ you can’t miss work for a week without telling anyone. Feeling inferior, Brockovich desperately pleads with Masry with her findings from Hinkley and the promise to be more respectful towards the work environment and rules. Brockovich comes to the internal realization that her charm and good looks (and breasts as mentioned in the script multiple times) may not always get her what she needs from a situation. Although subtle, this is an important shift in the hero’s journey. The turning point from the ‘old’ and ‘unsuccessful’ Brockovich to the raw, new, grown up hero that will inevitably save the day.

The Hero takes control
As Brockovich begins to take control of her destiny, she begins to notice the sacrifices she is making in her personal life. Her personal motive is taking a back seat in her journey of self-discovery as she is neglecting new boyfriend Jorg and her three kids in her process. Brockovich finds encouragement and reassurance in her second visit to Hinkley as multiple scenes of rising action show her connecting with the residents and uncovering important information for the file against PG&E. She
                                                                                                                                     Taylor 5

begins to displace her motherly instinct onto the effected people of Hinkley when she is away from her own children. Although PG&E may seem like the antagonist of the plot, we can argue that it is Brockovich’s ‘previous self’ that can sometimes be the antagonist as her past looms over her building success as a reminder that she may not be able to accomplish her goals.  Jorg is seen as the bad guy by the middle of the movie as he consistently reminds Brockovich of her neglect of her family.

A Monkey wrench is thrown
Although frustrated that she cannot be home more often, Brockovich is feeling positive about herself and her goals with this lawsuit. She arrives to work one day to find that Masry has partnered with a lawyer, Kurt Potter, who has experience with toxic chemicals. Masry tells Brockovich that Potter has made clearance with PG&E to get the residents $250 000 to be divided amongst the residents for their suffering. Brockovich is furious and tells the two of them how little money that really is considering the extent of the cost of each health crisis happening in Hinkley. Brockovich quits her job as her outer need to help Hinkley has been hindered.

Things fall apart
Masry attempts to convince Brockovich to come back as he sees her as an asset to the lawsuit because she knows so much about each family in Hinkley (a
                                                                                                                                     Taylor 6
pivotal scene shown mid-plot as Brockovich demonstrates exceptional care and motivation for the families). As Brockovich returns they are reaching a moment of clarity when they realize their little law firm is going head to head with a giant corporation. This is the moment of maximum remove when Theresa (Kurt Potter’s assistant) goes to Hinkley to continue Brockovich’s attempt at convincing town residents to join the lawsuit against PG&E. The residents do not like Theresa’s cold attitude and refuse to comply with further action until Brockovich is back. This is a logical consequence to Brockovich being taken away from the residents of Hinkley who she has bonded with over the past few months. Brockovich foresaw this disaster because her keen sense of people skills knew they would not respond well to Theresa. This disaster, triggered by the monkey wrench action was unforeseen by Theresa and Ed Masry. At this point, Brockovich has been stripped of her status enhancing position at the firm that was affirming her personal persuasion to work so hard to fulfill both her external and internal needs and motivation.

Hero hits bottom
Just when things cannot look any worse for Brockovich, her boyfriend and caretaker of her kids decides to leave her. This strips away her safety net at home where her personal motivations lie. Brockovich is faced with a tremendous decision of values when she is forced to decide if she is going to give up and find a new job (spend more time at home) or push through and risk it all by trying yet again with the residents of Hinkley. There is a pivotal character change in a scene where
                                                                                                                                     Taylor 7
Brockovich is with her baby and re-evaluates why she began this journey in the first place. She realizes it is important to her to prove to her kids that you can do anything if you set your mind to it (which relates again to her generic motive of proving an un educated woman can do anything). After returning to work she realizes that in order for the lawsuit to pass, they need all 624 residents of Hinkley to sign consent. A feat that Masry and the legal team deem impossible in the time frame given by the judicial system.  This detail was added to the script to create the high stakes needed for the hero to risk it all.

Hero Risks all
In true Erin Brockovich style, she goes to Hinkley again to work her inner truth of personable encounters and genuine spirit to get every single one of those signatures. Along the way she encounters a man who, impressed by her ‘go get them’ attitude, provides her with documented proof the PG&E knew about the contamination. It is clear to the audience Brockovich is working on genuine concern for the justification for these families and no longer just for her own personal motivation.

What does the hero get?
With the help of Brockovich, all 624 signatures plus the proof of contamination won the residents of Hinkley $333 million. Brockovich’s generic and categorical motives were satisfied with the help of the writers for the movie, as
                                                                                                                                     Taylor 8
many residents in real life were not happy with the results. Her personal motive was fulfilled as she received $2 million dollars and a permanent job where she could see her kids more often. The writers at Universal Pictures followed the classic character- driven journey structure to shape the story into a box office success.


















                                                                                                                                     Taylor 9

Works Cited

Burke, Kenneth. A Grammar of Motives. Berkeley: University California Press, 1945.
Erin Brockovich. Dir. Steven Soderbergh Perf. Julia Roberts, Albert Finney, and Aaron Eckhart. Universal Pictures, 2000. Film.



GEOG 2012 - Rural Regions: Poverty in Ontario, British Columbia and Atlantic Canada


Taylor 1
GEOG 2P50
Monica Taylor – 4522884
Prof. Michele Stairs
Nov 26, 2012
Word Count:

Rural Regions: Poverty in Ontario, British Columbia and Atlantic Canada

Canada’s strength, Robert M. Bone writes is “its regional diversity and ensuing political struggle to balance regional interests with national ones” (Bone 444). The uniqueness of Canada’s six geographic regions; Ontario, Quebec, British Columbia, Western Canada, Atlantic Canada and the Territorial North provide geographers with an opportunity to assess how issues related to geographical themes remain similar or change across the nation in different regions. This paper will be defining and analyzing issues of poverty in rural regions in Canada focusing on three specific political regions of; Ontario, British Columbia and Atlantic Canada. It is best to start with defining rural regions which defined by Statistics Canada is “all of those places located outside of Census Metropolitan Area (CMA) and a Census Agglomeration (CA) territories (a CMA has an urban core population of 100,000 and over and a CA has an urban core population of 10,000 to 99,999; each include all neighboring municipalities where 50 percent or more of the workforce commutes to the urban core)” (Burns et al, iv). 
The recession in Canada in the 90’s grew the number of poor people from 16.2% to 19.7% and since then the poverty gap has been widening and the number of poor Canadians increased by 10.1% from 4.3 million to 4.7 million (Canadian Council 2). What is interesting to
Taylor 2
see is how this increase in the poor populations in Canada has been affecting the rural regions the most versus the urban centers such as Toronto and Vancouver. Poverty is more difficult to manage in rural areas as accesses to resources are diminished or nonexistent. Research provided in the paper Poverty and Social Exclusion in Rural Areas address problems of rural areas and the risk of poverty in these regions. Two phenomena, they write, in western culture is effecting the populations and increases of poverty in rural regions. The first is urbanization, which is “the trend of drawing population out of remote rural areas and into urban and accessible rural areas” (European Commission 8) and counter-urbanization which is “the flow out of urban areas and into accessible rural areas” (European Commission 8). This paper is seeking to explore three political regions to see how rural regions are experiencing poverty in relatively similar ways (health care, child care and job loss) and at the end of the paper insight will be provided through governmental policies on the present and future attempts to fix the problems of poverty in these unique areas.
A common concern with rural regions, especially in Ontario, is how geography makes it hard for these regions to have access to services; public transportation, homeless shelters or soup kitchens. The physical space that separates rural regions from large urban centers forces the labor market in these areas to consist of low paying / minimum wage jobs. Those who can are living in rural areas and commuting to urban centers where there is better work. An example from rural Dufferin County are struggling to have their municipality create and control the policies for workers that live and work in the area with low paying jobs. There are unfair and unreasonable bylaws that the rapidly decreasing population of farmers are struggling to engage with. These farmers are being imposed upon by urban laws. “We don’t need that hassle” one Dufferin
Taylor 3
County Farmer writes to the local paper “so we sell out to a housing developer or quarry operator and save ourselves a lot of labor, poverty and pain. Farm families will probably disappear from Ontario in a quarter century” (Hooker). The rural stereotype as the article On The RISE defines as “the good life, characterized by close-knit communities, strong churches, healthy families and the abundance of good, home-grown food” (Sinkowski & Landon 14) This is not the case in many rural communities any more in Ontario as the threat of poverty looms over families who are struggling to make it work. Expenses are rising, especially because of the little to no choice in many mandatory services such as child care and health care. The one place you can get health care may be too expensive for your family, but you need to pay for it anyway. If that same family was living in the city, more options would be available.
Day care services for rural areas around Ottawa have taken a hit lately as $250 000 was pulled out of a $750 000 budget for improvements to subsidize daycare centers (Reevely). This is a local example of how governmental choices in political regions and across Canada affect rural regions in ways they may not see as a big deal but in fact are. In the article On The RISE, the authors speaks of how the government promised poverty would get better “many people focused their own hard work and the promised tax cuts, and resigned themselves to the actions of the government as we lost more and more of our welfare state” (Sinkowski & Landon 14).
Shifting our attention east to Atlantic Canada with an example from the article “A House with Two Families”; many families who live in poverty struggle with the dilemma of having food, heat or rent. The article focuses on the cost that poverty imposes on society, especially rural societies. “Poverty stops out economy from growing and dealing with it would be a huge economic and social lift. Poverty holds us back and robs our children of opportunity” (A House
Taylor 4
With Two Families). So what is the government doing about this problem which affects many people in rural communities in Eastern Canada? Former premier of New Brunswick, Shawn Graham’s recent speech to the liberal Party of New Brunswick suggested that job creation is the best way to combat poverty in rural communities. He continued to exemplify the Ocean Spray Corporation in Rogersville, investment in the $2 million potash mine in Sussex and support for home grown success stories like Barrett Explore (Xplornet Communications Inc) (Graham). He proudly announced that “15 000 new jobs were created even in the midst of the worst recession in a generation” (Graham). This speaks to the “social assistance reform” put in place by the provincial government as a two-tiered system that has “provided assistance to individuals with longer-term needs and those not considered employable, while municipalities provided assistance for people considered able-bodies and ready for work” (Saulnier 20).
But is this enough to sustain Atlantic Canada and keep rural regions from increasing levels of poverty? What makes Atlantic Canada as a political region unique is the geographical closeness that these rural communities have with each other. In the case of Ontario with its vast landscape and long distances between many communities, Atlantic Canada can share resources between small towns such as health care services. As in Ontario, the complex issues of expensive and inaccessible health care options are experienced in Nova Scotia. A large portion of homeless people are people with mental illness and addiction. Most service providers interviewed for the Poverty Reduction Policies and Programs paper indicated that there was inadequate access to mental health professionals citing long waiting lists, lack of beds and lack of information for clients (Saulnier 14). It is clear in Atlantic Canada that similar issues of the vicious cycle of not

Taylor 5
enough money for services and resources and the lack of affordable services and resources lead to increased poverty are seen across the country as well in other political regions.
On the west coast in British Columbia similar issues relating to poverty are seen in rural regions. The paper Economy, community and mortality in British Columbia, Canada explores 24 coastal rural communities to see the link between health and wealth. These communities represent the communities of the ‘Toward a Healthy British Columbia’ project, funded by the Canadian Institutes of Health Research; “a project that seeks to understand the social and economic determinants of health in non-urban, purportedly resource industry setting” (Veenstra 1810). Wealthier communities are proved in the paper to have over all healthier citizens and wealth influences health relevant attributes of communities such as; the nature of government policies, the quality of health care, pollution and environmental hazards, criminal activity, the nature of the distribution of wealth, the efficiency of transportation systems, safety in workplaces, social capital or cohesion and structured social inequalities, for example (Veenstra 1808). Let us examine this recurring theme of poverty and its relation to health care with an example from the media article “Better, cheaper health care”. An attempt to decrease health concerns and in turn decrease the amount rural citizens are spending on health care was made by allowing pharmacists to give flu shots. In 2012, 50 percent of the British Columbia rural population received a flu shot in comparison to Ontario’s 33 percent (Better cheaper health care). Keeping the cost of going to see a professional for flu shots keeps the threat of a more serious and expensive health concern down for those who are unable to travel to cheap health care options is important for rural citizens.

Taylor 6
British Columbia, like Ontario and Atlantic Canada struggles with the cost of day care services and lack of available and affordable services. “Average child care costs in B.C. range from $9000 to $14 000; a person working 37.5 hours per week at minimum wage earns about $20 000 a year” (Woo 1). Like this papers examination of Atlantic Canada and Ontario, many if not most rural jobs are minimum wage which provides a shocking description of how child care can send families into poverty. As a solution to this problem, a suggestion for the future to assist these families is to implement universal child care: “charging $10 a day for full time care, $7 a day for part time care and nothing for families that make less than $40 000” (Woo 1). Although this would help dramatically there are many other financial areas that burden rural residents and increase the looming threat of poverty.
Although the three political regions explored in this paper are geographically very different and spatially distant from each other the issues that surround rural areas in these regions are very similar. Using media articles from 2012 a current view on the intimate struggles these small communities have with job creation, child care and health care have led to a deeper understanding of what creates poverty in these regions and what sustains it. Looking into the future smaller rural communities can look to creative energies and innovation reflected in the article Let’s reflect on our strengths that are not only applicable to areas such as information-technology “but can be employed to keep traditional sectors like agriculture and forestry vibrant in the 21st century. Tourism and eco-tourism can provide a boost to our rural areas and small towns, given the advantages of our scenic natural vistas and welcoming small communities” (Let’s reflect).

Taylor 7
Putting rural Canada back on the policy agenda for the federal government is the next step of reducing poverty and increasing options available for rural communities struggling with poverty and attempting to reduce it. The standing senate committee on agriculture and forestry is urging the federal government to “adopt a series of explicit and precise initiatives to that a generation from now, rural Canada is a ‘place’ where, as a whole, population decline (in absolute terms and as a proportion of the total Canadian population) has been halted if not reversed and where, on a range of socio-economic indicators – health status, educational attainment, and per capita income, rural Canada has closed the gap with urban Canadians” (Beyond Freefall x). Although poverty is a concern in rural communities across Canada, this should not deter citizens from visiting and residing in these areas. There are many wonderful attractions to life in rural communities versus living in an urban one. Further education about the benefits of rural living may increase the amount of wealthy residents who want to reside in a rural area and commute to an urban setting job which will stimulate economy in these small towns. Policies and committee plans are already beginning to identify and resolve poverty issues in unique rural areas across Canada and rural living can become just as comfortable and desirable for those of a lower socio-economic status as living in a convenient urban region.






Taylor 8

References

“A house with two families”. Telegraph – Journal [Saint John, NB] 14 Nov. 2012:A.6. Canadian Newsstand. Web. 24 Nov. 2012. (MEDIA SOURCE)
“Better, cheaper health care”. The Ottawa Citizen [Ottawa, Ont] 17 Oct, 2012: A:12. Canadian   Newsstand. Web. 24 Nov. 2012. (MEDIA SOURCE)
Bone, R. The Regional Geography of Canada (Fifth Edition). Oxford University Press: Don         Mills, 2010. (ACADEMIC SOURCE)
Burns, Ausra, David Bruce, and Amanda Marlin. “Rural Povery Discussion Paper.” Rural           Secretariat Canada (2007): 1-75. Print. (ACADEMIC SOURCE)
Canada. Parliament. House of Commons. Standing Committee on Agriculture and Forestry.          Beyond Freefall: Halting Rural Poverty. Final Report. 39th Parl., 2nd sess., June. 2008.     Parliament of Canada. Web. Nov 24. 2012.  (ACADEMIC SOURCE)
Canadian Council on Social Development. “Poverty by Geography: Urban Poverty in Canada”    Urban Poverty Project 2007 (2000): 1-36. Print. (ACADEMIC SOURCE)
European Commission. Directorate-General for Employment, Social Affairs and Equal      Opportunities.. Unit E.2., Poverty and Social Exclusion in Rural Areas. European         Communities: 2008. Print. 1 – 187.  (ACADEMIC SOURCE)
Graham, Shawn. “The challenge of leadership”. Telegraph – Journal [Saint John, NB] 27 Oct.       2012:A.15. Canadian Newsstand. Web. 24 Nov. 2012. (MEDIA SOURCE)
Hooker, Charles. “The diminishing role of farmers”. The National Post [Don Mills, Ont] 23 Oct.             2012: A.15. Canadian Newsstand. Web. 17 Nov. 2012. (MEDIA SOURCE)
 “Let’s reflect on our strengths”. Telegraph – Journal [ Saint John NB] 06 Aug, 2012:A.5.             Canadian Newsstand. Web. 17 Nov 2012. (MEDIA SOURCE)
Reevely, David. “Council offers just a little to neediest citizens; $250, 000 taken from daycare to             help offset $7M provincial cut.” The Ottawa Citizen [Ottawa, Ont] 16 Nov. 2012: C.3.     Canadian Newstand. Web. 17 Nov. 2012.  (MEDIA SOURCE)
Saulnier, Christine. “Poverty Reduction Policies and Programs”. Social Development Report         Series (2009): 1 – 37. Print. (ACADEMIC SOURCE)
Taylor 9

Sinkowski, Carrie. & Landon, Sally. “On the RISE : Two Ontario women take a close look at the             often well-hidden face of rural poverty”. Briarpatch (Dec 2003 / Jan 2004): 14-16.      Academic Search Premier. Web. 17 Nov 2012. (ACADEMIC SOURCE)
Veenstra, Gerry. “Economy, community and mortality in British Columbia, Canada.” Social         Science & Medicine 56 (2003): 1807-1816. Print.  (ACADEMIC SOURCE)
Woo, Andrea. “Lack of cheap daycare major cause of child poverty, says advocacy groups”. The             Globe and Mail [Toronto, Ont] 22 Nov. 2012: S.1. Canadian Newsstand. Web. 24 Nov.       2012. (MEDIA SOURCE)

GEOG 2012 - Honey Harbor: Developing a Sense of Place


Honey Harbor: Developing a Sense of Place
Monica Taylor - 4522884
GEOG 2P06
TA: Amanda Amore
Submission Date: Thursday October 18, 2012
Brock University










HONEY HARBOR: DEVELOPING A SENSE OF PLACE                                                        2

Honey Harbor: Developing a Sense of Place
GEOG 2P06

Within the district municipality of Muskoka is a harbor town that, although small in size, provides a gateway to an incredible expanse of Georgian Bay waters and lifestyle. Honey Harbor serves as a launching point to the “30 000 islands that make up the Georgian Bay geography” (Honey Harbor, 2012). This town, with a population of 2124 (Census, 2012) serves as a base in this paper in the attempt to understand how this community can create a sense of place that expands itself far out into the expanse of cottages that line the waters and to the cottagers who use Honey Harbor as their marina and base for community and culture. In order to understand how sense of place is created, place itself must be defined and understood as the groundwork for creating a “sense of place”. Using three key features of personal experience as a cottager, the multiple layers of what creates a sense of place as well as constructing a working definition of what sense of place means to the culture of cottagers in that region will be assessed. First, using the physical landscape of water as means of travel to and from the cottage to the harbor creates the concept of place. A second layer is viewing the primal landscape of the region and a third layer is deconstructing how place based education is used to improve a sense of place for both locals and especially the seasonal cottagers.
A unique feature of Honey Harbor that assists in the creation of a sense of place is the water systems that are used by all cottagers and home owners to travel from one place to another. There is little road access which is a key element in understanding how place is developed. Yi Fu
HONEY HARBOR: DEVELOPING A SENSE OF PLACE                                                        3

Tuan, in his book “Space and Place: The Perspective of Experience”, describes space as “requiring movement from a place to another place – a place requires space to be a place” (Tuan, 1977, p.9). The community feeling on the water of going from a place that has been developed as “home” (cottage or home) to the small town of Honey Harbor (marina) connects the two in one entity that can be described as a “place” that has significant meaning to all those who use it. Tuan describes this phenomenon well by saying “Movements are often directed toward, or repulsed by, objects and places. Hence space can be variously experiences as the relative location of objects or places, and – more abstractly – as the area defined by a network of places.” (Tuan, 1977, p.12).
Once the concept of place has been established, moving towards an understanding of how feelings, memories and experiences effect a process called experiential perspective. Using such a personal place, it is easy to see how ones experiences with a place over time can anchor a sense of belonging. The concept of being able to relate to the world through the space and place in which you call home and spend your time is essential in developing as a person. The cycle of place affecting a person and in turn, the person affecting space is something that can be seen in Honey Harbor. An example of this is how a group of children who were fascinated with the boats on the water and began to paint paintings of what they saw and interpreted and sold them at the local store “The Bee Hive” in Honey Harbor. These children have created a sense of meaning and belonging through interacting with the space created by the water which connects them from their home/cottage to the main land. Cresswell describes this “conception of place describes a way of relating to the world. It insists that people have the burden of making their own meaning
HONEY HARBOR: DEVELOPING A SENSE OF PLACE                                                        4

in the world through their own actions. Key here is the idea of ‘experience’. It is this notion of experience that lies at the heart of the humanistic approach to place” (Cresswell, 2006, p.1).
Using personal experiences of primal landscape interaction assists in understanding how personally experiencing Honey Harbor throughout childhood develops a sense of place and how this development has implications for the space in the future. A primal landscape is defined by Measham as “landscapes that are concerned with the interaction that occurs between children and the environments in which they mature” (Measham, 2006, p.426)
Developing an attachment and meaning and in turn, sense of place, is directly influenced by learning about the environment around you. As a child, they have the ability to grow and learn about the world, that includes the landscapes available. Measham includes in his paper that “learning about our environments during childhood is strongly influenced by the direct experience of playing, as well as through the role of family, culture and community” (Measham, 2006, p.426). Honey Harbor, being such a small community, provides a unique experience for children as the community and culture is like a family. The learning and experiencing of landscape that happens throughout childhood is fostered by the community and family feeling. Many families are routed there and since cottages are usually passed down from generation to generation the attitudes and beliefs about the environment that are fostered in childhood caries on to adulthood. These adults are therefore more likely to feel that personal attachment and sense of place for Honey Harbor and make more personalized and caring decisions about environmental

HONEY HARBOR: DEVELOPING A SENSE OF PLACE                                                        5

choices (for example: who to vote for in municipal elections based on environmental care, proper boating measures on the water, waste disposal and proper shoreline management).
This idea of place – based education is especially important for the area of Honey Harbor as we build upon the importance of the experiences of those who live in the town and cottage areas especially as children. Place – based education is an attempt to help communities solve community problems through using students and school staff of the area. Place – based education promotes the focus on local examples and learning, which is important in developing a sense of place. Many people begin thinking at a local level and very quickly forget the importance of that specific place as they move onto broader thinking in terms of global scale issues and solutions. It is within the best interest of the school and municipal community to foster the concept of sense of place in students and teaching them how to bring that love of place and understanding of the unique landscape around them into action. It is this primal instinct that can ensure the reservation of local tradition and landscape preservation because people who make these decisions uniquely care about these places. We can see place – based education at work in the small local school: The Honey Harbor Elementary school. They are part of a program called the “Group of Seven”, this committee is school board wide and has each school focus locally on the environmental uniqueness of place and the environmental issues at hand and how they, as student, and later in life as adults can make positive changes. The program provides students with materials and an opportunity to share their findings with other schools and other regions through a conference once a year.
HONEY HARBOR: DEVELOPING A SENSE OF PLACE                                                        6

In conclusion, Honey Harbor, was used as an example of a landscape that has been transformed through the defining of space, primal landscape interaction and place based education in order to grasp the concept of what is sense of place. The local community of both permanent residences and seasonal cottagers will be able to make a difference in the preservation of the local landscape because of the unique sense of belonging and caring for the space and place around them. This study and understanding of landscape can be a productive way of exploring further implications that the environment can have on a community and on the culture present in the area. Honey Harbors gateway to the cottage lifestyle and beautiful Muskoka environments will continue to inspire future generations to develop their own sense of place through experiencing the landscapes around them.












HONEY HARBOR: DEVELOPING A SENSE OF PLACE                                                        7

References

Cresswell, T. (2009). Place. Royal Holloway: University of London.
Honey Harbor. (2012, October 2). General format. Retrieved from http://honeyharbour.net/
Measham, T.G. Learning about Environments: The Significance of Primal Landscapes       Journal: Earth and Environment Management. Volume 38, Number 3 (2006),       426-424.
Statistics Canada. (2011). 2011 Census of Population (Catalogue number 98-316-XWE).   Retrieved October 2, 2012 from Statistics Canada: http://www12.statcan.gc.ca/   census-recensement/2011/dp-pd/prof/index.cfm?Lang=E
Tuan, Yi Fu. (1977). Space and Place: The Perspective of Experience. Minneapolis:           University of Minnesota Press.